35 Algernon Street, Oatley NSW 2223
35 Algernon Street, Oatley NSW 2223
High-side 538m² lot | north aspect and pool | updated kitchen, original bathroom | Oatley Village and station walkable | catchment position
The property’s competitive strength is found in its combination of a quiet waterside cul-de-sac, a north-facing high-side position, and a usable 538 m² block. A functional three-bedroom layout is supported by an updated kitchen with servery and breakfast bar, while an inground pool and landscaped backyard add family appeal. An original tiled bathroom is the main finish weakness, but the configuration is solid and liveable. Walkable access to Oatley Village and the station, plus catchment placement for Oatley Public School and Georges River College Oatley Senior Campus, suits a family or owner-occupier seeking established character. It is positioned as upper-middle family stock within the suburb.
Value may be constrained by the original bathroom and by a land size that is solid but not in the street’s premium tier. The pool adds lifestyle appeal but may carry ongoing maintenance costs. The partial updating, namely a modern kitchen with older wet areas, suggests scope for improvement that could support price growth. Market conditions at resale might also shape the final figure.
Detailed Independent Property Report prepared by PropCred Analyst team for 35 Algernon Street, Oatley NSW 2223
Checks found:
Value Risk
2
Liquidity Risk
2
Planning Risk
Income Risk
2
Execution Risk
URL has been copied successfully!
Market Insight
Oatley is a tightly held, premium family market in Sydney’s St George area, with owner-occupiers at 79% and couples with children making up 53% of households. Demand is driven by established professionals aged 45-plus, many owning outright, against scarce stock: just 107 house sales in the past year, a 1.1% vacancy rate, and a 36-day median selling time. House price data diverge—one measure shows a 5.6% annual decline to $2.313m, another records a 10.2% compound rise to $2.7m—while units grew 8.4–16.6%. Rental yields are thin, at 2.1–2.2% for houses, though rents are firm at $850–$1,000 weekly. New projects worth $45.2m will add only 33 units, 10 townhouses and 3 houses, still undersupplying an area that sold 45 houses and 73 units in Q3 alone. Low turnover and limited land support prices, but the ageing profile and high entry point temper upside.
URL has been copied successfully!
PropCred Estimated Value
Comparable Sales: 35 Algernon Street sold $2.356M in March 2025 | Property Price Band: $2.4M–$2.5M | Value Drivers: land size, north aspect with pool, kitchen versus bathroom condition
Bedrooms
3
Bathroom
2
Parking
2
Land
537m²
URL has been copied successfully!